Free consultation with one of our specialists

Why not talk to one of our Medical Accounting Team. We can discuss your circumstances and then explain how we can help you achieve better financial management with a tailored fixed price plan.

Book a consultation

Training Costs : HMRC v Banerjee

Expenses for self-employed – any expenses must be incurred ‘wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the trade or profession’.
Expenses for employees – the restrictions for expenses that can be claimed by an employee are much stricter.  For an expense to be allowable it must be incurred, ‘wholly, exclusively and necessarily in the performance of their duties of employment’.

Traditionally the types of expenses that an employee can claim for have been restricted to fees paid to professional bodies, personal tools that the employer requires the employee to provide and business travel.

However, in the case, HMRC Vs Banerjee, a former registrar, successfully applied for and claimed a tax refund for courses and training costs which she had paid for personally. Prior to this case this type of expense had been disallowed when claimed by a surgeon as the courts had argued that the expense was not incurred ‘in the performance of his duties of employment’; those duties of employment being to provide care to the sick.

HMRC have now provided additional guidance in their manual EIM32530, regarding the circumstances and requirements which need to exist for claiming training costs.

If you think that you may be eligible to make a claim for training costs incurred in the last 4 years, we recommend that you first read this guidance provided by HMRC

You will see from this guidance that there are a number of pre-requisites required for making a successful claim:

  •  There is a mandatory requirement for the employee to undertake the external training as an intrinsic part of the duties of the employment and,
  •  Failure to complete the training and obtain the qualification will mean that the employee will not be able to continue in employment with the employer in the role that would otherwise have been available to them after qualification.
  • Any personal benefit incurred from the course, unlike most CPE courses, would be incidental and not therefore give rise to a dual purpose of the expenditure.

Some professional medical bodies are suggesting that their members may be able to claim the exam fees. This particular matter was not dealt with in the Banerjee case and it is uncertain whether HMRC will extend tax relief to cover exam fees.

The Revenue are reluctant to give tax relief on training expenses incurred based on one case which in many instances appears to contradict earlier legal decisions.

We are currently waiting for a response for a number of claims we have submitted for our clients based on this Banerjee case.

There is a 4 year limit on claims

It is possible to make a tax rebate claim up to four years in arrears. If the training expenses you have incurred include expenses going back four years, you may wish to make a claim now so that you do not miss the deadline.

How we can help you

We often provide a pro-forma letter for claiming tax relief on course fees for our clients to complete and submit to HMRC themselves.

Be aware, there may be a catch…

When a claim of this nature is submitted to the Revenue this automatically leads the Revenue to review the PAYE deducted in earlier years.  If, therefore, you have changed jobs at any time in the previous tax years or if your employer has operated an incorrect tax code for you, as is often the case, then it is possible for a taxpayer to find themselves with an additional tax liability rather than a tax refund.

If you are not completely sure that the Revenue have already reviewed the earlier years then we strongly advise against submitting a claim of this nature without first asking us to calculate if there is any underpayment that you are not aware of.

You will know that the Revenue have looked into an earlier year if they have sent you a form P800 or a claim for payment or refund for a particular year.



Contact us for specialist medical accountancy services for healthcare professionals

If you’re looking to plan your finances for the future or trying to find an answer to a problem then get in touch today.



Are you in danger of being hit with a huge tax bill on your pension growth? Our NHS Pension Review Service can provide an advance warning of impending pension issues.

Learn more →



HMRC have increasingly got GPs in their sights and many Practices have been subject to lengthy tax investigations. Make sure you’re covered with our annual insurance scheme.

Learn more →



Talk to one of our Medical Accounting Team for free. We can discuss your circumstances and how we can help you achieve better financial management, reduce your tax bills or plan for the future with a tailored fixed price plan.

Meet our team

We have a panel of subject experts and a team of professional accountancy support staff to make sure your specific needs are met reliably and cost effectively.


A specialist healthcare team to advise you
Call free for support at any time
Keep you up to date with the latest changes
No fuss, smooth process to change to us
Members of AISMA - Association of Independent Specialist Medical Accountants

What our clients say…

Dr William Jasper, GP Partner

We have received an excellent service since we moved to Nichols & Co. The transition has been the most hassle-free and transparent. They are always very helpful with any queries you might have and have a very good working knowledge of General Practice and are keenly aware of the challenges Practices face within the changing environment of the NHS.

We have been very impressed by the way Nichols & Co continue to deliver the range of services they provide from Accounts to Tax and NHS Pension advice.

At the year-end meetings, the accounts are presented in an understandable format without any unnecessary jargons. We have found Practice consultation and advice on Practice as well as personal tax matters from Nichols & Co specifically helpful.

We would not hesitate to recommend them to other GP Practices.

Dr C DeSouza, Salaried GP

I am a GP who works both in salaried and sessional roles. I have been with Nichols & Co for nearly three years. They have helped with my tax returns and can help with the range of different forms required in GP work. Danny and Shadmir have been accurate and efficient in their advice and guidance throughout. They have also been helpful and responsive when I have needed advice on the purchase of a car and also when looking to prove my income in order to get a mortgage. The system for providing income details and expenses is very easy to use and the summary they provide of how and when to pay your tax could not be clearer. I would recommend Nichols & Co to any colleague looking for an accountant with a good knowledge of GP work. 

Dr Ravi Bansal, Locum GP

I’ve been with Nichols and Co for nearly 10 years with Debra being my accountant. I first contacted them when I received letters for tax arrears due to the wrong tax codes being applied during my hospital jobs.

Debra sorted this matter out and has always provided helpful and honest advice regarding tax matters. She has also helped my wife with her tax returns. I would definitely recommend their services for accounting matters with a special interest in helping doctors with their tax affairs. They are approachable, helpful and efficient.

Dr David Paige, Consultant Dermatologist, The Holly Private Hospital

The reason I was first attracted to Nichols was when I heard Mr Nichols explain the complexities of the Life-time allowance and the Annual allowance changes in simple terms. I have had no regrets using this firm as they are very trustworthy and honest.

They also sorted out my allocation of rental income to my partner correctly which I had been badly advised on before by a very large and well known accountancy firm.

They respond in a timely manner to queries and (politely) chase me up over submitting my tax return details. I would recommend them to anybody in the medical profession.

Mr Muhammed Siddiqui, Hospital Doctor

As a trainee I was very unaware of the tax system when starting work. I was pursuing surgery and it resulted in paying for a lot of courses and locuming to support my journey. The tax system was very complicated and when I went to see Debra as I really had no idea how to start sorting out my tax affairs including correcting tax codes and what the locuming income meant for my current PAYE system and also how I could maximise my tax free amount with subscriptions.
I cannot thank them enough for helping. They really listened to my concerns and needs. I had never thought of getting an accountant until then and had never thought of stopping except for the fairness that Nichols and Co have dealt with me. They’ve taken me to a place where I am now beginning to do my own tax returns resulting in independence. Their ethical approach towards me has resulted in recommending my sister and other colleagues to seek their help. My emails are always answered quickly and appropriately. They are and, in particular, Debra truly exceptional accountants.